September 3, 2026

I Haven’t Missed a Thanksgiving Sweet Potato Pie in 40 Years… And There’s a Reason Why

The pie must bake until the center is set but still soft, otherwise it loses its creamy texture.

Tips & Tricks

  • Dry the puree if it seems too moist, because excess water soaks the crust and gives a less clean filling.
  • Add the spices gradually, especially nutmeg, because it can become bitter and cover the sweet potato’s mild flavor.
  • Protect the crust edges with a strip of parchment paper or foil if they brown too quickly, because the filling needs time to set.
  • Let it cool for at least two hours before serving, because the eggs finish setting the cream and allow a clean cut.

Creamy, just dense enough, with a crust that provides the crispy contrast.

FAQs

Can I make the sweet potato pie the day before?

Continue on the next page:
Share on Facebook